Part 4 of 9 · 1 min read
Structural and cross-cutting qualities
The qualities about how the code and the product are built, and the ones that cut across everything.
Structural qualities concern how the system is built inside. They matter to the people who change it.
| Quality | Plain meaning |
|---|---|
| Maintainability | How easy it is to apply changes and improve the system. |
| Extensibility | How easy it is to plug in new features. |
| Configurability | Whether users can change settings through a usable screen. |
| Portability | Whether the system must run on more than one platform. |
| Upgradeability | How easily a new version replaces an old one on servers and clients. |
| Installability | How easy installation is on all needed platforms. |
| Supportability | How much technical support and logging is needed to debug problems. |
| Localization | Support for several languages, currencies and units. |
| Reuse | Ability to share common components across several products. |
Cross-cutting qualities do not fit one group and touch the whole design.
| Quality | Plain meaning |
|---|---|
| Security | Whether data must be encrypted, and which sign-in methods are required. |
| Authentication | Proof that a user is who they claim to be. |
| Authorization | Rules for what each user may do. |
| Privacy | Hiding information, even from staff of the same company. |
| Legal | Laws and rules the system must obey, such as data protection. |
| Accessibility | Access for all users, including those with disabilities. |
| Archivability | Whether data must be archived or deleted after a period. |
| Usability | How little training users need to reach their goals. |
Common mistake
Treating this list as complete. Any list of qualities is partial. A system may have a quality of its own: one team once insisted that every design must survive losing a whole country office, and called the need "Italy-ility". Listen to the real concerns, and name them.
Check yourself:
- Is "the app must support English and Hindi" operational, structural or cross-cutting?
- Which group would "a user may only see their own orders" belong to?