Part 8 of 9 · 2 min read
Choosing the qualities for three systems
A worked comparison of three different systems, each with a different top three.
Choosing the qualities for three systems
The same method on three systems shows how different the answers are. This table is an example. In real work the answers depend on the facts of each case.
| System | Driving qualities | Why | Quality given less weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| School notice board | Usability, low cost, maintainability | Small, steady use. A volunteer maintains it. | Elasticity, availability beyond 99 percent |
| Concert ticket site | Elasticity, availability, security | Huge bursts. Downtime at sale time loses the sale. Payment data. | Extensibility |
| Hospital records system | Reliability, security, privacy | Mistakes can harm people. Data is sensitive and legally protected. | Performance beyond reasonable speed |
For each, the design shape follows. The notice board can be one small server. The ticket site needs the ability to add many servers fast and a plan for the first minute of a sale. The hospital system needs careful access control, full audit trails and strong copies of the data.
A good habit is to write the driving qualities at the top of the design document, with a one-line reason each. Every later choice is then checked against them: "Does this help elasticity, availability or security? If not, is the cost worth it?"
Check yourself:
- Which quality would you give less weight on a notice board, and why?
- What would you add to the hospital design that the notice board does not need?
Words you will meet
| Word | Plain meaning |
|---|---|
| Architecture characteristic | A quality of the system that shapes its design |
| Operational quality | Seen while the system runs |
| Structural quality | About how the code and parts are built |
| Cross-cutting quality | Touches the whole design, such as security |
| Scalability | Performing well as users grow steadily |
| Elasticity | Coping with sudden bursts, then shrinking |
| Availability | Share of time the system works |
| Recoverability | How fast it returns after a disaster |
| Driving characteristics | The top few qualities that matter most |
| Least worst design | The design whose weaknesses hurt least |
| Fitness function | An automatic check that a quality still holds |