Part 5 of 12 · 2 min read
A pause needs a time limit, and the limit's default must never be "approve"
Think of a parcel locker that sends a package back if nobody collects it within a set number of days. It does not leave it on the street indefinitely. It does not hand it to whoever walks by next.
In plain words: default-deny means that if no decision arrives, the action does not happen -- a pause with no time limit can wait forever, and worse, a pause whose timeout default is "approve" turns every sufficiently slow reviewer into an automatic yes, which defeats the entire purpose of having a gate.
A worked example. With a 30-minute mean wait for a decision and a 60-minute timeout, 13.5% of approval requests exceed that timeout and never get an answer in time. Extending the window doesn't make the problem small: at a 30-minute timeout, 36.8% of requests exceed it; even at 120 minutes, 1.8% still do, because an exponential wait always has some probability of running long. Every one of those timed-out requests needs a defined outcome -- and that outcome has to be stop or re-plan, never silently proceed.
The key lines. From code/mini-hitl/hitl.py:
# from code/mini-hitl/hitl.py
def timeout_outcomes(wait_mean=30.0, timeout=60.0):
"""Share of approvals that time out: P(wait > timeout) for an exponential wait."""
return math.exp(-timeout / wait_mean)
Read it as: the formula has no upper bound built in. math.exp(-timeout / wait_mean) is always strictly greater than zero. There is no timeout long enough to guarantee every request gets answered in time. That is exactly why the system needs an explicit rule for what happens at the deadline. A timeout is not a rare edge case that can be left undefined.
Default-deny
Default-deny means that if no decision arrives, the action does not happen.
Example: 13.5% of requests timing out at a 60-minute limit is not a bug to be engineered away -- it's the expected behaviour of a system with real human response times, and default-deny is the rule that makes that 13.5% safe rather than catastrophic.