CSE Roadmap

Common tier · about 3 hours · 12 parts

Part 4 of 12 · 2 min read

Price between a floor set by cost and a ceiling set by customer value

The vendor's cost sets a lower bound on any sane price; the customer's own savings set the upper bound.

Think of pricing a tutoring service. You cannot charge less than what it costs you to run a session. You cannot charge more than what the lesson is worth to the student compared with hiring someone else.

In plain words: a price has two natural bounds — the floor is the lowest price that still hits your target margin on cost, and the ceiling is roughly what the task is worth to the customer — and the actual price has to land somewhere between them.

A worked example. At a $0.227 cost per task and a 60 percent target margin, the price floor works out to about $0.57 per task — below that, the vendor is losing money relative to its own margin target. The ceiling, from the customer's side, is roughly $2.20 per task: the 55 percent chance the agent resolves it times the $4 a human would have cost the customer to do it instead. Anywhere between $0.57 and $2.20 is a defensible price; where exactly depends on competition and willingness to pay, which this module's model doesn't capture.

The key lines. From code/mini-pricing/economics.py:

# from code/mini-pricing/economics.py
def price_floor(cost, target_margin):
    if not 0 <= target_margin < 1:
        raise ValueError("target_margin must be at least 0 and below 1 (a margin of 1 needs an infinite price)")
    return cost / (1 - target_margin)

Read it as: the floor is cost divided by (1 minus the target margin), not cost plus a markup. Dividing instead of multiplying is why a 60 percent margin target needs a price 2.5 times the cost, not 1.6 times it. This is a distinction worth getting right before quoting a number.

Price floor and ceiling, usage/seat/outcome-based pricing

The floor is the lowest price that reaches the target margin on cost; the ceiling is roughly the value to the customer. Usage-based pricing charges per task or token; seat-based charges per user per month; outcome-based charges only for resolved outcomes.

Example: the $0.57-to-$2.20 range above is the floor-to-ceiling band for this task — which of the three pricing styles to use within that band is a separate question, covered next.